The 1990s Are Back in J&K as PM Modi Returns to His Roots
The 1990s Are Back in J&K as PM Modi Returns to His Roots
jkupdate.com | 27-Nov-2018 02:56 PM
Prime Minister Narendra Modi.
There was a time, starting with his Independence Day speech in 2014, when even Indians who had not voted for Prime Minister Narendra Modi imagined that they too could be a part of his growth and development vision for India.
This belief was reinforced in March 2015 when the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) formed a coalition government with the People's Democratic Party in Jammu and Kashmir. In those months – despite odd attacks on churches, provocative statements of his party and ministerial colleagues, and a sangh affiliate's controversial Ghar Wapasi campaign – it appeared that Modi was willing to put the divisive past behind him.
Forget Indians who had not voted for Modi; since August 2017, as dissatisfaction triggered by the slapdash roll-out of GST grew, it became evident – borne out repeatedly by election verdicts since the Gujarat result – that even large sections of those who did vote for him were no longer backing him.
This sense deepened in June after Mehbooba Mufti resigned, following which BJP pulled out of the coalition and withdrew support to the PDP.
The dissolution of the State Assembly last week has further pushed BJP to its core agenda.
Instead of being a party which raised hopes and displayed promise, Modi has shepherded it back to being a political force whose triumph or failure depends solely on its capacity to raise fear of the imagined other, and heighten worries of a power vacuum in the event that people don’t vote him back to office.
Departure from Mookerjee and BJP's Vision for J&K Relations
To understand, there is need to analyse what Modi jettisoned in March 2015 when he and BJP president Amit Shah were in attendance, when Mufti Mohammed Sayeed took oath as chief minister of Jammu and Kashmir along with BJP's Nirmal Singh as Deputy Chief Minister, besides other 23 other ministers from the two parties.
It was a courageous decision to align with the PDP. To do so, Modi had to silence the slogan which served as his party's clarion call on J&K for 62 years since 1953. The slogan was coined by the party in memory of its iconic founder president, Syama Prasad Mookerjee, after he died in June 1953 in Srinagar jail where he was detained for forcibly entering the state despite orders to the contrary:
Jahan hue balidaan Mookerjee,
woh Kashmir hamara hai
(The Kashmir where Mookerjee laid down his life, is ours)
Neither was the air rent with this emotional slogan to convey sense of satisfaction of being in power in a 'lost' state – albeit in a coalition – nor did any of the party leaders or cadre give voice to what they have grown up with – Mookerjee's slogan, or the rhyme, he shouted along with party activists, including 29-year-old Atal Bihari Vajpayee, in the course of his agitation on Kashmir:
Ek desh mein do vidhan,
Ek desh mein do nishan,
Ek desh mein do pradhan,
Nahin chalenge, nahin chalenge ...
(In one country, there cannot be two constitutions, two heads and two flags)
Since Mookerjee's death, abrogation of Article 370 of the Indian Constitution which grants autonomous status to the state along with a separate Constitution, was one of the three contentious issues that was the BJP's hallmark, contributing to its claim of being a party with a difference.
Between 1998-2004, when Vajpayee was prime minister, the BJP was often questioned why it put the three demands on the back-burner. The stock reply used to be that the party did not have a majority of its own.
But post 2014, with the BJP having a majority of its own and not being dependent on coalition partners, this response would not have sounded convincing. This was especially true because the BJP did not dilute its posture on the other two disruptive demands: construction of Ram temple and introduction of Uniform Civil Code.
The formation of the coalition was not billed as evidence of majoritarian triumph in the only Muslim-majority state, despite this having been the stated objective since the Jana Sangh days. Each of BJP's 25 seats were located in predominantly Hindu-majority seats of the Jammu region.
The association with PDP, a party that was often questioned in the past for its ambiguity on militancy, indicated that BJP under Modi was putting a greater emphasis on realpolitik and less on political fundamentals.
The BJP had mounted an audacious Mission 44+ campaign for the 2014 Assembly polls. Despite this acrimonious campaign, its decision to align with the PDP indicated a visible departure from Mookerjee's and BJP's past visions of the state’s relationship with the rest of India. Modi realised that as the national helmsman, he had to view challenges in the state beyond what the party was accustomed to.
Modi Retreats to his Comfort Zone – Vituperative Politics
In utterances, Modi and colleagues indicated the necessity to leave behind the 3Cs – conflict, contradictions, cynicism. Instead, they had to follow just one mantra: R – reboot or reconciliation. Clearly, the party realised that to resolve conflict, dialogue and joint action were the only ways to reinforce the region's pluralistic heritage and extricate itself from the quagmire it has been trapped in for decades.
Yet, Modi squandered the chance of securing the love and affection of the Kashmiris like Vajpayee did. His reiteration of Insaniyat (Humanism), Jamhooriyat (Democracy) and Kashmiriyat (Kashmir's age-old legacy of Hindu-Muslim amity) rang hollow because the Centre faltered on every pledge it made, the worst being the lack of urgency on the flood rehabilitation package.
The situation worsened after the generational transition in PDP following Mufti's death. From April 2016, when Mehbooba Mufti became chief minister, the BJP's engagement in J&K was not with an eye on ushering normalcy into the state.
Instead, each of its utterances and actions was aimed at maximising support for BJP in its core constituency in the rest of India.
There is little doubt that the BJP faces an uphill battle in 2019 and this cannot be won on the basis of this government's performance. To prevent the parliamentary hustings being reduced to a state-wise aggregation of polls, the BJP requires a set of emotive issues. This plank has been under construction for the past several months.
The majoritarian platform contain several elements – Ram temple, fresh confrontation in Varanasi, renaming of cities and towns, continuing campaigns for cow protection and against Love Jihad, and so on.
The BJP's latest tactics on Kashmir and its declaration that the state requires no special treatment coupled with the continuing tough posture on Pakistan completes the bouquet of Hindutva-centric issues with which the BJP will approach the electorate.
As far as Kashmir is concerned, there is now little to differentiate between the sentiment of the fringe that supports BJP and the party's mainstream. The BJP's promise of a paradigm shift is now a mirage.
The optimism of 2015 has faded as Modi has retreated into the comfort zone of vituperative politics.
In the hope of consolidating Hindus to vote on the basis of their religious identity, he has lost the support of those who considered him a pragmatist and not a committed ideologue. The wheel has come full circle for Modi, and also for J&K.
While Modi’s return to his roots was possibly inevitable, the state’s return to the crisis of the early 1990s is a bigger tragedy than it appears to be.(Courtesy:The Quint)
(The writer is an author and journalist based in Delhi. He can be reached at @NilanjanUdwin. This is an opinion piece and the views expressed above are the author’s own. The Quint neither endorses nor is responsible for them.)
Tags: Mehbooba Mufti JKupdate News PM Narendra Modi Bharatiya Janata Party People's Democratic Party JKupdate JKupdate editiorial
1 of 40
Over 4500 vehicles leave for Jammu after remaining stranded for about ..
2 of 40
Curfew continues for 3rd day in Jammu
3 of 40
Governor announces Rs 20 lakh ex-gratia for NoK of CRPF man martyred i..
4 of 40
Curfew To Continue In Jammu For Second Day
5 of 40
Chopper Services today resumed in Gurez valley
6 of 40
740 Security Forces Personnel Killed in 12 years in JK; 23 percent of ..
7 of 40
Security of Hurriyat leaders will be removed: Home Ministry
8 of 40
Ladakh division to be headquartered in Leh, Kargil: Governor
9 of 40
4 more CRPF men succumb, Lethpora attack death toll mounts to 49
10 of 40
45 CRPF Men martyred, 38 Injured In Deadliest Attack On Force In JK
11 of 40
05 Drug Peddlers arrested in Ganderbal; 15 KG poppy straw seized
12 of 40
Denying Kargil its rightful share another stride of Delhi’s divisive p..
13 of 40
Soldier commits suicide in Jammu
14 of 40
Explosion in a school in Pulwama, 12 students reported injured
15 of 40
Slain militants killed in Chadoora gunfight identified
16 of 40
Governor directs Divisional, Dy Commissioners to ensure availability o..
17 of 40
NDA’s Rafale deal 2.86 percent cheaper than UPA’s: CAG report
18 of 40
JSS Kathua ranked 2nd position in 30th Road Safety Week celebrations
19 of 40
12 year old girl dies in a road mishap in north Kashmir
20 of 40
Two militants killed in encounter with security forces in Budgam
21 of 40
15-year old killed in mysterious blast in Kupwara
22 of 40
Modi Mantra of development will sweep Parliament elections: Avinash Ra..
23 of 40
Kathua Police solved firing incident case,Accused arrested alongwith w..
24 of 40
No connection between ISJK and groups operating in Iraq and Syria: MHA..
25 of 40
RDD to construct Waste Segregation Plants in every village of Budgam: ..
26 of 40
One Day Workshop organized on Presentation and Communication Skills
27 of 40
Governor expresses grief over demise of Pt. Vidya Rattan “Aasi”
28 of 40
35A Row: JRL calls for complete shutdown on 13,14 Feb in valley
29 of 40
02 Soldiers martyred, militant killed in encounter in Pulwama district..
30 of 40
Jammu-Srinagar highway remains closed for seventh straight day
31 of 40
Police files 2 FIRs against stranded passengers, students
32 of 40
Div Com reviews status of development projects, exhorts expeditious co..
33 of 40
Advisors Kumar, Skandan for action oriented approach to develop JK's M..
34 of 40
Sufficient stocks of medicines available in Kashmir valley: Div Com
35 of 40
JK govt seeks adjournment of Article 35A hearings in Supreme Court
36 of 40
Advisor Kumar declares open North Zone qualifying round at SMVDSB Spor..
37 of 40
NABARD organized State Credit Seminar
38 of 40
Committee of secretaries formed to ensure justice with Kargil: Governo..
39 of 40
DC Shopian takes stock of essential services, tours hilly areas of the..
40 of 40
Kashmir valley shuts down to mark Maqbool Bhat death anniversary